• 未分類

What Agreement Was Reached With The Great Compromise Answers.com

Small States have disproportionately more power in the Senate.At the time of the Convention, the population of States varied, but not as much as it does today. As a result, one of the most important political implications of the Great Compromise is that states with smaller populations have a disproportionate voice in the Nation`s Congress. The question of representation, however, threatened to destroy the seven-week-old convention. Delegates from large states believed that because their states contributed proportionately more to the nation`s financial and defensive resources, they should enjoy proportionally greater representation in the Senate as well as in the House of Representatives. Delegates from small States demanded with comparable intensity that all States be equally represented in both chambers. When Sherman proposed the compromise, Benjamin Franklin agreed that all states in the Senate should have the same voice on all matters except those involving money. Small states with smaller populations argued that such an agreement would lead to unjust domination of large states in the government of the new nation, and that each state should have equal representation regardless of its population. This means, for example, that even though Wyoming has only three votes in the Electoral College, with the smallest population of any state, each voter represents a much smaller group of people than any of the 55 electoral votes in California`s most populous state. On 14 June, when the Convention was ready to consider the report on the Virginia plan, William Paterson of New Jersey requested an adjournment to give some delegations more time to prepare an alternative plan. The request was granted, and the next day Paterson tabled nine resolutions containing the necessary amendments to the articles of Confederation, followed by a lively debate. On June 19, delegates rejected the New Jersey plan and voted to discuss the Virginia plan. Small States were increasingly dissatisfied and some threatened to withdraw. On July 2, the Convention was blocked to give each state an equal vote in the House of Lords, with five states divided by yes, five by “no” and one by one.

. no State may be deprived of its right to vote equally in the Senate without its consent. [10] The agreement reached under the Grand Compromise of 1787 was that all states would be equally represented in the Senate and that they would be represented proportionally in the House of Representatives. June 1787, a legislative power composed of a single house. Each State should be represented on an equal footing in that body, regardless of population. The New Jersey plan, as it was called, would have let the articles of the Confederacy go into effect, but would have modified them to increase the powers of Congress a little. [3] At the time of the Convention, the South grew faster than the North, and the Southern States had the most extensive Western claims. . .

.